Declined A Way for clan members to help other members.

[Potdindy 866]

In any casual clan, there are better equipped players and worse ones. I have several kids in my clan who are really fun to battle with, but their k/d is around .50 because they have terrible equipment. What if there was a way for bigger members to give crystals to lesser ones, perhaps even at a loss. For example, I have 10k crystals and can give that to another guy but he will only get, say 7.5k. I would argue for an even trade of value, but that might be abused. I think it would build good community by encouraging generous players to help out others. This would also help close the buyer vs nonbuyer gap. The only other way I can imagine helping smaller acct out would be to login one's self on their acct, but that seems to be banworthy here unfortunately. Thoughts?

[Maf 32,355]

Declined

 

Developers said multiple times that there will never be any kind of way of transferring funds to other accounts for free. Even at a loss. Sorry, won't happen.

[Potdindy 866]

Thanks for answering, Sorry if this has been asked before. Have they ever spoken as to why they don't want this?

[wolverine848 13,097]

Thanks for answering, Sorry if this has been asked before. Have they ever spoken as to why they don't want this?

They would not allow because the "lesser" player receiving funds would be at an advantage over all other tankers of the same rank.

10k (or whatever) at lower ranks can make a huge difference.

 

If clan members only ever played against other clans it might not be such a problem.

But since clan members can join any battle the problem exists.

 

Aside from all of the above reasoning - they want people to spend $$.  If the lesser member needs better equipment Tanki would rather that extra gear be obtained through spending $$.

[Maf 32,355]

Thanks for answering, Sorry if this has been asked before. Have they ever spoken as to why they don't want this?

They would not allow because the "lesser" player receiving funds would be at an advantage over all other tankers of the same rank.

10k (or whatever) at lower ranks can make a huge difference.

It's not even that. It's all about economy. I guarantee you that there are hundreds of Legend players, who have millions of crystals they literally don't need (e.g. someone who only plays format battles won't need to buy and upgrade all other equipment and modules). Such players can join a clan and start giving away their crystals to those who actually need them. As a result the receiving players are less likely to purchase crystals for money, which, according to devs, would result in a very quick catastrophic failure of the game's economy.

[mr.bryant 36]

maf doesn't like charity ): 

[ThirdOnion 4,898]

maf doesn't like charity ): 

I guess you think Legends donating 100k crystals to recruits so they can get OP tanks at the very beginning of the game is fine?

[wolverine848 13,097]

It's not even that. It's all about economy. I guarantee you that there are hundreds of Legend players, who have millions of crystals they literally don't need (e.g. someone who only plays format battles won't need to buy and upgrade all other equipment and modules). Such players can join a clan and start giving away their crystals to those who actually need them. As a result the receiving players are less likely to purchase crystals for money, which, according to devs, would result in a very quick catastrophic failure of the game's economy.

me-thinks you neglected to read the last paragraph in my post.   ;)

[GuidoFawkes 2,361]

just get the buyers to drop golds for the non buyers

and get the powerful players to give flags to the weak ones