smokey v thunder

[GENTALMAN14 0]

VOTE IN THE POLL :D

Edited February 28, 2013 by GENTALMAN14

[wishness 10]

I think smokey is more dangerous, since critical hit is actually frequent. For thunder, it is dangerous with double power as it can destroy Mammoth m3 in 3 shots, but it is useless since there are many thunder protection paints and many users brought them at higher ranks.

[splitterpoint 10,986]

Smoky is more dangerous... you never know when they unleash their nuke-shot.

Thunder dents the tanks these days due to the massive amounts of thunder protection paints on the battlefield.

Edited February 28, 2013 by splitterpoint

[MusicJam19 737]

Thunder all the way

[Jayjey419 41]

Smokey ^ you mean ;)

[r_ELain_3S0 17]

Smoky is far more dangerous. Now 90% of battles are running on the luck of the Smoky users, spoiling the gameplay.

[williew 1,999]

I self like thunder more than smoky..

Smoky have a good cirtical hit, but I like the splash of the thunder more..

But the only disatventage is that you kil youself if you shoot against walls or enemy tanks..

In TDM there many self destructs by thunder users.. :(

Conclusion: thunder the best ;) and the worst :(

[Moreuz 67]

I guess it depends on how you play.

 

In we see it in this way, with Thunder you deal with more damage (not counting in the critical hit of Smoky) each time you take a shot, and expose yourself from a covering position to shoot.

Smoky fires so fast that if you want to deal as much damage in as short time as possible, you will not be able to go back and forth between cover.

 

But with Smoky you can shoot at enemys and they will feel like they get shot at non-stop, it will be hard to control the tank somewhat and harder to aim. So Smoky can protect itself in this way, just like Twins except not as effective. It don't need cover so much if it's fighting only one enemy at a time, as the non-stop firing will make it hard for the enemy.

 

 

But personally... I like Thunder the most! It feels more satisfying when I know that each shot does more damage. Plus I use the splash-damage alot sometimes, it's really great. If I used Smoky I would probably feel as if I have to expose myself all the time to shoot a tank, like if I'm defending. But Smoky really is VERY annoying to meet in battle... like 2 skilled Smokys shooting at you at once. Its horrible! And they will reach any distance!

[jalenpen 9]

Smokey all the way... Constant rate of firing can throw the thunder's aim off. +criticals

[dungu 25]

M0= Thunder

M1= Thunder

M2= Smokey

M3= Smokey

Assuming both gunners using Titan or Mammoth hulls

Wasp & Hornet hulls M0 ~ M3 = Thunder

Hunter, Viking & Dictator hulls M0 ~ M3 = 50-50 chance

[wishness 10]

50-50 chance for what? Thunder or Smokey?

[Raaish 26]

Well, I came back after a long time, and from what I saw in the last battles, Thunder is better than Smoky. (In maps like silence). Thunder can do the splash damage, doing an area affect, and even do damage if you shoot at the ground, or wall closer to your enemy. Thunder FTW in camping :) . Smoky has the Crit, but Smoky is sometimes a bit hard to aim. Comparing those 2 in Close-Combat, The smoky will win because of the fast reload( Like the stupid twins :ph34r: ). And the thunders damage-yourself affect. (although you can self-destruct :lol: ) so I wud say THUNDER FTW!

[dungu 25]

50-50 chance for what? Thunder or Smokey?

50% chance for Smokey to win, IF the Crit comes, IF not the Thunder win

[Moreuz 67]

Is it so that the splash damage is not affected by hight, in a strange way?

 

If you stand on the higher ground in Silence for example, and shoot at the wall of a building with Thunder and an enemy is near the wall but way below, will that still cause plenty of damage?

[WookySpolf 63]

I will cause some. Why I love Thunder is for that very reason... they think they're safe... how wrong they are... <_<

[RedBull123456789 3]

Player RedBull123456789 has been banned for a week. Reason: unreasonable, disrespectful criticism of the game and its authors, Owner; any activities that have an adverse effect on project development (Forum).р 2.14 Rules

Edited March 2, 2013 by SuperNick95

[Panzer5454 3]

The winner depends on range.

[Finnshaman 5]

Quite arbitrary, but I think Smokey and Thunder are only effective against say Mammoth if he/she does not figure out in time where the granades come.

Usually I wipe them off with Shaft easily if they maintain their position. But 70% of times regarding those 2 guns, I choose Smokey to unbalance and terrorize w/ the firing rate, just like Twins. They make the enemy waggle like drunken drivers:)

[Raphael2 3,263]

How to answer "sometime" to "thunder vs smokey" ?!!

[r_THE_GREAT_WHITE1 6]

Hello,Well for my opinion Thunder is The best .

[Valletta 834]

Thunder is boss for clan wars, since there are no protection paints there, but on the regular battlefield it feels nerfed...

[jokjinari 160]

Thunder is fun smoky is fun, but I would say that thunder would win. I really like to play with smoky though.

Thunder is boss for clan wars, since there are no protection paints there, but on the regular battlefield it feels nerfed...

 

So clan wars are never with protective paints?

Edited March 2, 2013 by jokjinari