[Declined] Small reward for getting an idea implemented in TO?

[Epic_Space_Mango18 592]

It's not common an idea actually gets used in the game, so for those few that do, maybe the creator of the idea should get a small reward? Maybe premium account for a week? 5,000 crystals? 5 gold boxes? NOT altogether, I'm just suggesting what a possible reward could be.

[Maf 32,348]

Declined

 

We already had this idea before. You can find my answer in the previous topic, but in one sentence: your reward is the fact that developers saw your idea and implemented it. Your motivation for posting ideas should be the desire to improve the game, not a possibility of getting a reward.

[Epic_Space_Mango18 592]

Declined

 

We already had this idea before. You can find my answer in the previous topic, but in one sentence: your reward is the fact that developers saw your idea and implemented it. Your motivation for posting ideas should be the desire to improve the game, not a possibility of getting a reward.

I don't mean it in that way just to get rewards. More of just a way to say thanks?

[Benefactor 6,892]

Or how about penalties for putting up bad ideas? The penalty grows exponentially on each consecutive bad idea.

This should clear up the clutter.  :)

[ToiletPaperRoll 1,318]

Or how about penalties for putting up bad ideas? The penalty grows exponentially on each consecutive bad idea.

This should clear up the clutter.  :)

no pls dont riddler_8 will be bankrupt  :(

[Maf 32,348]

I don't mean it in that way just to get rewards. More of just a way to say thanks?

I get what you mean, but the moment we start giving out rewards, people will start spamming pointless ideas to get them.

 

I already asked Cedric about this a while ago and he said with utmost certainty that this won't happen.

[DageLV 940]

Tanki wants to be "Orginal" and wants you to think that they cme up with that idea and wont give you a credit. Thats it.

[Epic_Space_Mango18 592]

I get what you mean, but the moment we start giving out rewards, people will start spamming pointless ideas to get them.

 

I already asked Cedric about this a while ago and he said with utmost certainty that this won't happen.

Never thought of that o.O

 

Also, I wonder if anybody will get the 400,000 reward (200,000 for both if they get it) for video for the week

[Benefactor 6,892]

I get what you mean, but the moment we start giving out rewards, people will start spamming pointless ideas to get them.

 

I already asked Cedric about this a while ago and he said with utmost certainty that this won't happen.

 

Or how about penalties for putting up bad ideas? The penalty grows exponentially on each consecutive bad idea.

This should clear up the clutter.  :)

[railguniz4noobz 2,394]

Ok then. 1 week chat ban for putting up a bad idea. perma ban if its a really bad idea.

[Benefactor 6,892]

Ok then. 1 week chat ban for putting up a bad idea. perma ban if its a really bad idea.

This is going to be one really quiet section of the forum.....

[DESTROYER_13 1,019]

Ok then. 1 week chat ban for putting up a bad idea. perma ban if its a really bad idea.

And who is to judge if the idea is bad? It may seem good for the players, and bad for the mods, or vice versa. Some people like the 15 min battles, some don't. It is just a matter of opinion, there is no certain good or bad, depending on the idea. It would be unfair to punish for a "bad" idea, it will just be a big mess.

 

There should just be acknowledgement that the tanker has contributed to the game, if rewards aren't possible, and although more could be done, the [completed] sign does show that. It would be nice if there was a list of players who have contributed to the game.

[Maf 32,348]

Or how about penalties for putting up bad ideas? The penalty grows exponentially on each consecutive bad idea.

This should clear up the clutter.  :)

That yields another problem. We have a lot of creative players on the forum, but some of them are relatively new to the game and don't fully understand how the game (and the company) works. So they end up posting a lot of ideas, many of which end up being "bad" due to lack of experience and knowledge. Right now these people will have their topics declined and will see an explanation as to why, so that they can keep it in mind when posting their next idea. Thus they have a chance to improve. But if we add any kind of penalty for bad ideas, those players will be discouraged from posting here and as a result we will lose a lot of potential great ideas from players.

[Epic_Space_Mango18 592]

That yields another problem. We have a lot of creative players on the forum, but some of them are relatively new to the game and don't fully understand how the game (and the company) works. So they end up posting a lot of ideas, many of which end up being "bad" due to lack of experience and knowledge. Right now these people will have their topics declined and will see an explanation as to why, so that they can keep it in mind when posting their next idea. Thus they have a chance to improve. But if we add any kind of penalty for bad ideas, those players will be discouraged from posting here and as a result we will lose a lot of potential great ideas from players.

Like a brief reason why a player invites you to a battle...missed a few gb rains since I didn't know why they were inviting me

[Mario3108 462]

I think here should just have an acknowledgement for those players who make great ideas or even which later are implemented into the game.

But it is not the right way. I think there should have a detail in the players' profile which says us their contribution in this community. :)

[Benefactor 6,892]

I think here should just have an acknowledgement for those players who make great ideas or even which later are implemented into the game.

But it is not the right way. I think there should have a detail in the players' profile which says us their contribution in this community. :)

 

Contributions: 1

[Mario3108 462]

Contributions: 1

You mean "Contributions in this topic"  ^_^

[Quarks 2,255]

Tanki wants to be "Orginal" and wants you to think that they cme up with that idea and wont give you a credit. Thats it.

No, that is not it. They have never claimed, to my knowledge, that they want to take all the credit for an idea. Also, as players, we never know if our ideas have already been conceived in planning. And to quote Maf, "the moment we start giving out rewards, people will start spamming pointless ideas to get them."

[bigx 14]

I agree there should be no monetary reward for an idea implemented for the reasons given already, but maybe for those ideas chosen by the devs there could be a special 'ideas' paint or maybe a tank graphic available, perhaps even to buy at a much-reduced rate. 

[railguniz4noobz 2,394]

I would rather have an ideas paint than 10k crystals. 

[DageLV 940]

No, that is not it. They have never claimed, to my knowledge, that they want to take all the credit for an idea. Also, as players, we never know if our ideas have already been conceived in planning. And to quote Maf, "the moment we start giving out rewards, people will start spamming pointless ideas to get them."

Premium idea. Do you see any credit to the person who made that idea? No u dont. Why? Tanki climed it.

[Mario3108 462]

The ideas must be suggested with the intention of improve Tanki. Simple.

There is no necessary any reward, even if the idea is the best one ever.

[DieselPlatinum 5,121]

how about the rewards can be a pie right in the face, you get to chose the type of pie :P